Jessica Lange Shuts Down American Horror Story Return: “Oh Christ, No!”

Well, if you were hoping for a Jessica Lange comeback in American Horror Story Season 13, you might want to rethink those daydreams. The iconic actress, known for her killer roles that have snagged her multiple Emmys and Oscars, gave a pretty definitive “no thanks” when quizzed on whether she’d return to her old haunted stomping ground. In a recent red-carpet chat with an Irish radio station, the 75-year-old Lange didn’t mince words: “Oh Christ, no. I mean, I haven’t done it for more than 10 years, 12 years, so, no, I’m not doing it.”
Lange was a standout in the anthology series, gracing viewers with her presence in five seasons, where she portrayed unique characters—from the eerie Constance Langdon in the original season to a powerful witch in Coven and a bewitching nun in Asylum. In fact, she hasn’t appeared in this horror rollercoaster since a brief stint during 2018’s Apocalypse. Lange’s departure surely marks a pivotal point for the series, given her powerful performances helped shape its identity early on.
On the flip side, Sarah Paulson, another fan-favorite from AHS, seems all-in for another round! In a recent chat with Good Morning America, she expressed her eagerness, saying, “I think there is a big chance that I will return… I would like to do it more than anything. It’s my home.” Paulson’s emotional connection to the series is hard to overlook; she became a household name playing a variety of characters over seven seasons, proving her versatility and keeping audiences on the edge of their seats.
So, while Lange might have slammed the door on her return, fans still hold onto the sliver of hope that other iconic characters might make their way back into the world of American Horror Story. Let’s face it—this anthology thrives on twists and surprise appearances! Will Season 13 be the one to bring back some familiar faces? Only time—and perhaps a sprinkle of Ryan Murphy’s signature horror magic—will tell.
Sources: Celebrity Storm and Entertainment Weekly, Good Morning America, Deadline
Image Credit: Title: Untitled, Author: No author info, License: [‘cc_publicdomain’, ‘cc_attribute’, ‘cc_sharealike’]