From ‘The Notebook’ to ‘The Last Song’: Ranking Nicholas Sparks’ Tearjerkers
If you’ve ever found yourself reaching for the tissues while tuning into a Nicholas Sparks movie, you’re definitely not alone. These films, which have reportedly raked in over $750 million globally, straddle the line between sappy love stories and heart-wrenching tragedies. Despite not always hitting the mark with critics—most Sparks adaptations are often compared to Hallmark films—they draw audiences in with their predictable plots and emotional punch. Let’s take a closer look at how these adaptations stack up, from crowd favorites like “The Notebook” to the less-loved entries like “Safe Haven.”
Starting at the bottom of the barrel, “Safe Haven” manages to topple even the lowest expectations set by Sparks’ canon. With a plot twist involving ghostly intervention, the film left audiences either scratching their heads or rolling their eyes. A domestic violence survivor, played by Julianne Hough, tries to cobble together a new life in Southport, only to be pursued by both her abusive ex-husband and a ridiculous plot twist. This one is currently streaming on Starz if you’re feeling brave.
Next up, we have “The Last Song,” where Miley Cyrus shines in a tale of estranged father-daughter dynamics against a backdrop of romance and tragedy. Despite including the heartstring-tugging original “When I Look at You,” the film falters with its overly happy resolution, leaving a sugary aftertaste that might make discerning viewers gag. Catch this syrupy film on Hulu.
Then there’s “The Best of Me,” a flick with a compelling premise that gets derailed by an eye-roll-inducing organ donation subplot. The tale of former lovers reconnecting amidst personal tragedy has its moments, but alas, the outlandish plot twist is like adding a little too much sugar to your coffee—unnecessary and oddly off-putting. You can find it available on Starz.
Rounding out the pack, “The Choice” features an actor line-up that feels more like a two-for-one deal at a bargain bin than a blockbuster. Cheating and community judgment loom large over our leads, portrayed by Benjamin Walker and Teresa Palmer, who fail to ignite any real chemistry. You can take the leap into this lukewarm romance on Peacock.
Overall, whether you crave an emotion-laden escape or simply want to see how Sparks’ adaptations play out, you’re likely to find your guilty pleasure among these films. Just don’t forget the tissues—wherever you source them from!
Sources: Celebrity Storm Wire and Entertainment Weekly, People Magazine, The Hollywood Reporter
