Brooks Nader Dances Around Dating Rumors with Alcaraz and Sinner at the US Open

Maya Rivers here, a wannabe poet who cannot resist turning a red-hot rumor into a lyric you can hum while scrolling. A lamp-lit theater of tennis gossip lit up the 2025 US Open as Brooks Nader found herself center court for all the round-the-rumor gossipers. The chatter swirled around whether the Love Thy Nader star was casually dating two young tennis phenoms, Jannik Sinner and Carlos Alcaraz, at the same time, and whether either man knew about the other. Spoilers: she offered a reply wrapped in charm and the kind of deflection that could only come from a veteran of witty talk-show banter.

On September 17, during an appearance on Watch What Happens Live, Brooks was pressed by a fan with a question that could fuel a dozen tabloids. Did Sinner and Alcaraz know about each other if she were dating both? Her response was as nimble as a net cord: “A lady never kisses and tells, especially twice. That’s just not nice.” The quip landed with a wink and a chorus of approving laughter from host Andy Cohen, and even Brooks’s sister Grace Ann Nader weighed in from the audience, tagging in with a playful nudge that suggested a second “boyfriend” angle. The moment was light, but the vibes were electric, hinting at how seriously fans love to read between the lines when it comes to athletes and romance.

Brooks quickly reframed the conversation. Dating, she noted, can be a loose term in today’s social world, and she kept the door ajar rather than slammed shut. “I mean dating is such a loose term these days. It’s just you know, I don’t know,” she said, earning an approving clap from the audience and a supportive cheer from the room. The singer of the night, so to speak, wasn’t alone in this delicate dance. Her sister Grace Ann had already spoken on the matter in another interview, suggesting the Carlos rumors had been true in some form. But even Grace Ann added a caveat about definitions, whispering that the Spanish star might be “the man of the hour,” while acknowledging she had not yet met him.

Publicly, Carlos Alcaraz has kept quiet about the dating chatter, but a Spanish journalist offered a different lens, relaying whispers from inside Alcaraz’s circle. According to Alberto Guzman on No Somos Nadie, picked up by 20 Minutos, Carlos is not in a confirmed relationship and has asserted his single status within his inner circle. The rumor mill, which never tires, pressed on as other romances in the sports world gained headlines—like Trinity Rodman and her own public kiss that signaled a new chapter in tennis-soccer crossovers—reminding fans that love in the era of screens and instant updates moves at the speed of a serve.

If you crave the bigger picture, the piece threads together other notable relationships in the sports sphere, including high-profile courtships and Instagram confirmations among stars who orbit the same limelight. While Brooks’s public stance here is a blend of playful deflection and sisterly spice, the broader takeaway is a culture where dating chatter thrives on how much can be inferred from a glance, a caption, or a shared room at a major tournament. The tension between private life and public fantasy continues to be a magnet for fans who want romance to be as dramatic as a championship match, even when the truth stays softly tucked away behind a velvet rope.

What’s next in this saga? The world will keep watching as Brooks navigates the rumor mill with the same poise she brings to the red carpet, and as Carlos and Jannik’s lives remain under the microscope of a hungry press and a star-struck fanbase. Will there be a definitive revelation, or will the romance rumors keep looping like a rally that never ends? Stay tuned to see who dares to be the next headline grabber in this sparkling, unpredictable arena of love and sport.

Sources: Celebrity Storm and E! News, No Somos Nadie, 20 Minutos
Attribution: Countries that do not celebrate New Year’s Day on 1st January — Jirka.h23 (CC BY-SA 4.0) (OV)