35 Years Later: The Unsolved Gardner Museum Heist and the Hunt for $500 Million in Stolen Art
Thirty-five years after two men dressed as police officers waltzed into Boston’s Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum and walked out with $500 million worth of art, the case remains one of history’s most baffling mysteries. And yet, Anthony Amore, the museum’s Director of Security and Chief Investigator, is still holding out hope that the stolen masterpieces—including works by Rembrandt, Vermeer, and Degas—will one day return to their rightful place. Because apparently, optimism is the only thing harder to steal than a Rembrandt.
The heist itself was less *Ocean’s 8* and more *Dumb and Dumber*. At 1:24 a.m. on March 18, 1990, the thieves convinced the museum’s night guard to let them in by claiming they were responding to a disturbance. Once inside, they handcuffed the guards, stashed them in the basement, and spent the next 81 minutes casually cutting paintings out of their frames like they were redecorating their living room. Among the stolen treasures were Rembrandt’s *Christ in the Storm on the Sea of Galilee* and Vermeer’s *The Concert*, both of which have been missing ever since.
Amore, who has been on the case for nearly two decades, is quick to dispel the myth that this was the work of a sophisticated criminal syndicate. “That’s movie stuff,” he scoffs. Instead, he believes the thieves were likely “common local criminals” who had no idea what to do with their ill-gotten gains. And while theories abound—from wealthy collectors hoarding the art in secret vaults to mobsters using the pieces as bargaining chips—Amore insists the paintings are probably still close to where they were stolen.
One of the most tantalizing leads involved alleged mobster Robert Gentile, who died in 2021 without ever revealing what he knew. “We have overwhelming evidence that points to him knowing something,” Amore says, “but he took it to his grave.” Despite the dead ends, Amore remains undeterred, fielding daily tips and working closely with the FBI. Most of the leads, however, are less “breakthrough” and more “fanfiction.”
So, will the case ever be solved? Amore thinks so, but his definition of “solved” is refreshingly pragmatic: “The only thing in the world I’m interested in is getting the paintings back on the wall.” Prosecution? Who cares. Justice? Overrated. Just give the art back.
Closing Remark:
And so, the hunt continues—a testament to human stubbornness and the enduring allure of a good mystery. Here’s hoping the next 35 years bring fewer theories and more Rembrandts.
Sources: Celebrity Storm and People Magazine
Image Credit: Title: Untitled, Author: No author info, License: [‘cc_attribute’, ‘cc_nonderived’, ‘cc_publicdomain’]
